James Crossley's blog Contact: jgcrossley10 - AT - yahoo - DOT - co - DOT - uk

Monday, June 01, 2009

Special or General?

I refer of course to the SBL Forum piece Michael Bird with (q: what's the difference between 'with' and 'and' in a partnership?) Craig Keener and much discussed on blogs. I have nothing to add on what's best, who's wonderful etc but maybe I will add a different comment on, well, some concepts of 'general'.

The NT isn't very big really but it is made big, so to speak, by the sheer amount of scholarship and no doubt it will become increasingly difficult, or increasingly bigger, as more and more gets written. But is being an expert in Paul, Jesus, and something else in the NT very general in terms of primary source material studied? I just don't know and it will depend on definitions etc but it seems this debate could further place NT studies in a ghetto. I mean, couldn't we define a generalist as someone who could do interesting things beyond NT and couldn't a specialist be someone who could do things on Paul and Jesus. Well, it's all definition I suppose.

An analogy: Shakespeare studies. Are specialists those who focus on Hamlet while generalists can cover tragedies AND comedies AND poetry? No doubt there are plenty of experts on some very precise detail - there always are and I can appreciate that - but this analogy makes NT studies seem a little odd, at least to me. Though not having anything like enough experience of Shakespeare studies, I imagine there's loads written - there certainly was when I was when I was an undergraduate. But I have been at conferences where scholars can move from Shakespeare to Beckett to whatever without it at least seeming unusual.

Perhaps reception history could change these matters. If people want to look at themes and texts through the ages, then that would require something beyond mere specialism...right...?

13 Comments:

Blogger Geoff Hudson said...

Become a theologian - they dream all day long.

June 02, 2009

 
Blogger Colin Toffelmire said...

Seems to me that one of the things that makes biblical studies so odd is its fascination with one particular group of texts. Your example of the Shakespeare scholar is a case in point. Such a scholar probably thinks of him/herself as some kind of literary critic who has a particular interest in Shakespeare. You hear a lot less about literary critics who have a particular interest in the Dtr History, or functional linguists who happen to work with ancient Hebrew. Many other academic disciplines seem to focus upon a methodological point (or points) of entry into the world, and apply that methodology to multiple sets of data. Biblical scholars start with a set of data and then apply a multiplicity of methodology to that data. Probably there are other disciplines that do this as well, but it is a little odd in any case.

June 02, 2009

 
Anonymous steph said...

All specialists are generalists as well if they're any good. People at the top intellectual end of churches are obviously generalists - like Burridge and Jim. :-)

June 05, 2009

 
Anonymous Christopher Shell said...

On 'and' and 'with':
'And' implies equal partners; 'with' implies that the first-named is the main player and the second a sidekick whose input was less. E.g.: Biblical Interpretation by Robert Morgan with John Barton (or is it the other way round?).

June 05, 2009

 
Blogger Jason said...

Well, whatever the case, I say you are generally special, James. If not especially general.

June 08, 2009

 
Blogger Jason said...

Oh, and sell Ronaldo for 100 mil pounds, buy Ribery and then some.

June 08, 2009

 
Blogger N T Wrong said...

Review Dale's new Jesus book. Go on.

June 09, 2009

 
Blogger Author Perry Ennis said...

Messiah is Coming...Are YOU Prepared?

Shalom,

I discovered your blog through Google Alerts when I was researching more on "Messiah". Your topic is exactly what my book is about. I was wondering if you'd do me the honors and check out my website and blog.

Website: http://www.messiahiscoming.net
Blog: http://www.authorperryennis.blogspot.com

I thought you might be interested in purchasing my book called, "Prepare for the Coming of Messiah". You can read more about it on the reviews, endorsements, and through my video.

I teach and minister at Congregation Beth Yahshua (House of Jesus) in Greenville, NC. I’ve been given a mandate by our Creator to be a watchman on the wall for our final generation—an honored position to spread God’s word while the foundations of our society are quickly shifting. I passionately warns others of the catastrophic events that are coming to planet earth, but yet we have so many blessings and I’m left with an uplifting hope. I’m so thankful for the restoration—all those who believe in Jesus Christ as their savor.

This is what some of my followers are saying about my book:

“This book is solidly based on the Bible, and Perry has filled the pages not only with a deeper understanding of the mysteries of these end times, but also a comprehensive and compelling overview of God's entire redemptive plan for His people. I have never read one single book that answered SO many of my questions, and finally cleared up so many of the things in Scripture that had remained a mystery to me.” >Kelly Ferrari, Door Keeper Ministries<

"Prepare for the Coming of Messiah" is indispensable to the library of those seriously seeking a deeper walk with our Lord Yahshua. Highly recommended!" >Rhonda Kendle, Spokane, Washington<

I’ve spent 26 years of collaborated research of the prophets. I’m proud to share the messages and deep in my heart is a burning passion for ALL those to read, “Prepare for the Coming of Messiah”. Through his latest book called, “Prepare for the Coming of Messiah”. You will gain the message of love, restoration, warning, and hope, a theme you will never tire to read over and over again.

If you know of others who would benefit from this book, please pass on this information. I'd much appreciate your extra servant duties.

“This is a must have end-of days book! Perry Ennis has a critical message for these end-times when the clock is tick-tick-ticking. Ennis gives a thorough breakdown of prophecies that help piece together and make sense of often difficult to understand Revelation prophesy. He gives excellent teachings on our Hebraic roots and the pertinent significance of Holy feast days such as Passover, the Feast of Unleavened Bread and the Feast of Pentecost, to name a few.” >Rhonda Kendle, Spokane, Washington<



God bless;


Perry Ennis
Expert in Prophetic Analysis
Inspirational Author of “PREPARE for the Coming of MESSIAH”
http://www.messiahiscoming.net

Please follow me on twitter: http://twitter.com/messiahiscoming

Direct Purchase Link: http://astore.amazon.com/premiumpromotionalservices-20/detail/0979688736

June 10, 2009

 
Anonymous The Penguin Press said...

Hello,

We are interested in sending you a book for review. The title is "Defenders of the Faith" by James Reston Jr. If you are interested, please email us back at elizabeth.yeh@us.penguingroup.com and we will send you a copy.

Thank You,
Elizabeth Yeh

June 11, 2009

 
Blogger Geoff Hudson said...

And the original NT is very much smaller than the extant version, by the time you have taken out all the editorial, that is all that has been fabricated

June 23, 2009

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I thought you might be interested in learning about OUR Jewish traditions which embrace the real Christ. We are the Frankist Association of America. One of our members has a new book out:

http://www.amazon.com/Real-Messiah-Throne-Origins-Christianity/dp/1906787123/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1245892844&sr=8-1

These are our teachings passed on through generations. If you can't afford the book you can see the website of one of our teachers - http://www.stephanhuller.blogspot.com.

Shalom

Beth El Jacob Frank

June 26, 2009

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ed Jones said,
For a rconsruction of "Christian" Origins which takes account of the anachronistic character of the term "Christian" while being representative of the thought of three of arguably our most authorotative criticcal historical theologians, take a look at: R. Joseph Hoffmann - wordpress. This is an archive of Hoffmann essays. Scroll to essay titled "Why the Historical Jesus is Important" - 6 Comments. Comments !&5Contain the Hoffmann letter. Disregard my Comments 2,3 and 4.they are reactions to a 4 day delay in publishing Comment 1.
It might just be worth your while.

June 30, 2009

 
Blogger Ed Jones said...

Ed Jones said:

Oops! Correction to my 7:10 PM Comment: The name of the Hoffmann essay should be: "The importance of the Historical Jesus".

September 20, 2009

 

Post a Comment

<< Home